This Protein Worms in Dirt Recipe Will Bring you Back to 4th Grade.

Posted on October 30th, 2019 By in Recipes Read Time: 12 mins.

This Halloween, we’re bringing you straight back to Elementary school (minus the guy who put gum in your hair as a way of showing his love for you) by reviving the iconic worms in dirt recipe (but with a twist!)

Spooky, yet delightfully tasty!

“Ew Grossssss!” We would all scream in a chorus of delight when someone’s Mom brought in a version of the popular chocolate-y dirt and worms dessert.

I mean.

What kid doesn’t love a concoction that combines Oreos with chocolate pudding, more Oreos, GUMMY worms (Ohh speaking of gummies, go checkout our ‘Yummy Gummy’ flavor of YUMINO EAA!), and more Oreos?

Exactly. We all loved it. And today, we’re bringing back the iconic worms in dirt recipe…

Only THIS time, with an APOLLO Protein Power up – so that you are in the best shape possible come Halloween night. Because let’s face it – The Peterson’s driveway is still 1/4 mile long and straight uphill. 😅

But let’s get right down and dirty and start making our spooky, high protein dessert concoction!

Before your make dirt and worms dessert, grab all the stuff you’ll need:

Protein Worms in Dirt Ingredients:

  • 1 Packet ‘Jell-O’ brand chocolate pudding
  • 1 Scoop of any chocolate protein powder (I used our Chocolate Peanut Butter flavor, but Molten Chocolate also works perfectly)
  • 2 Cups Milk (Dairy or Non-Dairy)
  • ‘Chocolate Sandwich Cookies’ (Oreos)
  • Gummy Worms
  • 2 Cups Whipped Topping (cool ‘hwhip’)


Okay first, crush up some Oreos (I used about 16 of them) in a zip-lock bag using a rolling pin. Don’t worry about separating the filling / frosting from the cookie.

Next, you’re going to make your pudding for this high protein dessert.

You can make this over the stove-top or just mix together cold.

Combine instant pudding mix with protein powder and milk, and stir.

*I used a half-packet of pudding, along with one scoop of APOLLO protein. You can play with your own ratio depending on how thick you like your pudding, but keep in mind it will get thicker as it sets!

You can heat your pudding in a saucepan or combine at room temperature. Refrigerate for 30 minutes – 1 hour to let the pudding set and cool.

Once your pudding is set, mix your Cool Whip into your pudding, along with about half of your Oreo crumbles.

And now it’s time to plate!

Portion your concoction into 6 small cups.

For Added Style Points, layer the rest of your Oreo crumbles into the cups as you ladle your concoction into the glasses.

Now as a finishing touch, add some of your gummy worms onto the top, and serve!

Spooky Perfection!

Call/Text: +1 (855) 823-9604

Email Us: [email protected]

2023 UNICO® Nutrition | All rights reserved

These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Our products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.


Take the hassle out of ordering, and save some serious 'mulah by signing up for autoship.

Simply go to the product you want, and choose either bi-weekly, or monthly cadence to get started.

Shop Now →

*offer ends 05/28/24 11:59 pm pst*

You Must be New Here!

We are best known for our yummy protein powders, energizing pre-workouts, and our collagen.

Drop us your e-mail and text number below - we'd love to share more about what we are all about.

We'll even send along a special 20% OFF intro offer too.

Looking for personalized product recommendations? Take our Superhero Quiz!